Is this trade fair?

[rob327]

I'd Give:
Tom Brady or Jake Plummer
Edge James
Seattle or Tampa Bay Defense


I'd get:
Jon Kitna
Fred Taylor
Stl. Defense.

Also, any update on Jake, is he coming back this week? Who do u guys think (non-bias please) will have the bigger 2nd half Brady or Plummer?

[koondaddy]

I dont think it is a fair trade. I would keep plummer for sure I have him and when he plays he gives me a nice score. I would keep edger he will come around, and for the defense stl is good but not that good. This is just my opinion so just take it for what it is worth. Good luck!!!!

[AsianOrange]

I try to pick up Fred Taylor...he's my savior on my team.

[Chronic_Toker]

If you're gonna do the trade, then make it:
Tom Brady
Edgerrin James
Seattle Defense
Definitely hold on to Plummer and Tampa D.