PDA

View Full Version : McGahee for Jackson?

LbloodOjunkieG
08-20-2006, 11:06 AM
Alright, so somebody offered me Donte Stallworth for McGahee, which I think is rediculous. I have a question about a counter offer. I am thinking of McGahee for Darrell Jackson. If you had this team:

QB - Brett Favre
WR- Plaxico Burress
WR- Donald Driver
WR- Mushin Muhammad
RB - Clinton Portis
RB - Ronnie Brown
TE - Chris Cooley

K- Jason Elam

Defense - Baltimore

Bench
RB- Willis McGahee
RB- Reuben Droughns
RB- Frank Gore
RB- Kevan Barlow
WR- Deion Branch
WR- Joe Jurevicious


Would you do it? I am on the fence, seeing as how I have Branch, who can be a nice 3rd reciever, but the problem is he is holding out. If I trade Willis, I will essentially have 2 running backs on my bench, whoever is starting for San Francisco. Any input would be apreciated.
BaileyTheBest
08-20-2006, 11:44 AM
well, you are pretty thin at WR but i don't know if i would make that trade. try to see if you can snag a little better of a WR for mcgahee. if you did make this trade, you would not have much depth at RB which you will need with portis's shoulder.
WABronco
08-20-2006, 12:49 PM
What the...

Are you in like a 4 team league or something?

But yea, I'd try that trade. DJack will be the first option in SEattle's potent passing game...
LbloodOjunkieG
08-20-2006, 02:01 PM
No, I am in a 10 team league. I had the 7th pick. I think I will take the advice and try to get a better wide reciever.
underrated29
08-20-2006, 02:09 PM
willis should have a good year this year, i bet he will suprise some.

i would hold on to him or get something better
GridironChamp
08-20-2006, 02:14 PM
Dont trade Willis, thats my advice. Trade Brown or CP dont trade Willis. And i woudl still try to get a much better WR that is more consistant.
LbloodOjunkieG
08-20-2006, 02:30 PM
Why would you trade CP or Brown before him? Do you think McGahee will have a better year?
GridironChamp
08-21-2006, 03:04 PM
Why would you trade CP or Brown before him? Do you think McGahee will have a better year?
Ya, i think McGahee is in for the big year, from the Fantasy Magazines i've read this is a very shared opinion. He was doing good last year as we all know. thats just me though, i would trade someonw with a little higher value atm, and keep someone who i think will do alot better during the season.

But of course if you trade Brown or CP you get a better WR than for Willis.
WABronco
08-21-2006, 03:54 PM
No, I am in a 10 team league. I had the 7th pick. I think I will take the advice and try to get a better wide reciever.
Yea, perhaps I'm just a bit in shock after going through a 14 team, 16 round draft. You're pretty heavy in RB's, so I'd make the trade.