NFL.com ranks all 32 QBs

[Peyton&Eli_fan]

So, what do you all think of Peyton at #6? Fair considering he's coming off a major injury and didn't play last year I think.

[Remedy]

Yeah Shaub is a toss up for me. I like him but I think some overrate him. I still think he should be above Flacco though.

And yes Stafford is far to low. If they want to put Newton up there they have to put Stafford higher considering his amazing last season.

yeah.. not sure how they can bump cam up that far and leave Stafford that low.
but alas everyone is entitled to an opinion I suppose though I can't say I understand the logic.

[johnlimburg]

yeah.. not sure how they can bump cam up that far and leave Stafford that low.
but alas everyone is entitled to an opinion I suppose though I can't say I understand the logic.

Lets not give him to much credit. I don't think the guy used logic

[watha?]

I knew people would overate Eli after the Superbowl. And I like cam but he is not top 10. Maybe after this year he could be but not now. And matt Ryan the glorified game manager made the top 10 no surprise there since they are still trying to shove him down peoples throats as being the next best thing.

Eli is still the current sb mvp winner, he's the last qb left standing last year. He should be #1, everyone else you can argue over for.

[shawinkerpoppin]

Eli is still the current sb mvp winner, he's the last qb left standing last year. He should be #1, everyone else you can argue over for.

the niners and ravens were pretty much a play away from advancing to the super bowl. Would we be having a discussion as either one of those being #1 if there teams won a super bowl? Brees Brady Rodgers and Peyton were hands down better before eli won the super bowl and are better after he won the super bowl. I bet my entire savings that the next QB that wins a Superbowl will skyrocket into peoples top 3 list rather its cutler romo rivers whatever.

[Jay3]

Aaron Rodgers #5? Fail.

[samparnell]

Jason Smith be lovin' him some Cam Newton.

[AllEyezOnZach27]

Aaron Rodgers #5? Fail.

Agreed! Guy just won the MVP and was a Super Bowl MVP the year before. How he isnt either #1 or #2 is amazing to me.

My personal top 20 QB's in the NFL...

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
E. Manning
P. Manning
Big Ben
Rivers
Vick
Stafford
Flacco
Ryan
Newton
Schaub
Cutler
Romo
Dalton
Palmer
Freeman
Fitzpatrick
A. Smith

Just my

[watha?]

Agreed! Guy just won the MVP and was a Super Bowl MVP the year before. How he isnt either #1 or #2 is amazing to me.

My personal top 20 QB's in the NFL...

Rodgers
Brady
Brees
E. Manning
P. Manning
Big Ben
Rivers
Vick
Stafford
Flacco
Ryan
Newton
Schaub
Cutler
Romo
Dalton
Palmer
Freeman
Fitzpatrick
A. Smith

Just my

how can you say that and still place eli at 3rd?

[baphamet]

does this list only go by last year? if not its a terrible list. actually, even then its still pretty bad.

[Charlie Brown]

Colt McCoy outperforms Sam Bradford, yet:

The ones who could someday crack the top 15
18) Sam Bradford, St. Louis Rams: I can't wait to see how well he does now that he has actual receivers to throw the football to. He could make the biggest jump on this list between now and the end of 2012. Possible breakout.

The ones who make the top two-thirds of this list possible
30) Colt McCoy, Cleveland Browns: He's the top dog in Cleveland, until the Browns draft Ryan Tannehill (or not). I've seen glimpses of how good he can be. But just glimpses. Eventually you have to put it together no matter who's blocking for you.

OH, the IRONY.

They rave about Bradford and how they "can't wait to see how well he does now that he has actual receivers to throw the football to". Yet, for McCoy "he is the top dog until Tannehill".

[AllEyezOnZach27]

how can you say that and still place eli at 3rd?

Last time I checked Eli never won a NFL MVP award. Eli is finally turning himself into the overall #1 pick everyone thought he could be. He still isnt on the same level as A-Rod, Brady & Brees but is in that next tier that is still great. If Peyton Manning proves that he is healthy and can have a productive season then he will jump up to #3 or #4 depending on the season that he has compared to the rest.

A-Rod is the only QB in the NFL right now that is a true 5 tool QB. He is ultra accurate, great arm, good decision maker, can run when needed and is a great leader.

[jcdavey]

i completely agree with eli being the current #1

his 2011 season was EPIC and super clutch all year

i agree with rivers`summary, but i disagree with cam being ranked ahead of him

i have a minor problem with peyton`s ranking but only because he sat a whole season

[Freddie Black]

The top 5 are interchangeable, assigning an actual number would just be arbitrary and an exercise in futility.

Matt Ryan is not a top 10 quarterback.

[JakeNbake]

Colt McCoy outperforms Sam Bradford, yet:

The ones who could someday crack the top 15
18) Sam Bradford, St. Louis Rams: I can't wait to see how well he does now that he has actual receivers to throw the football to. He could make the biggest jump on this list between now and the end of 2012. Possible breakout.

The ones who make the top two-thirds of this list possible
30) Colt McCoy, Cleveland Browns: He's the top dog in Cleveland, until the Browns draft Ryan Tannehill (or not). I've seen glimpses of how good he can be. But just glimpses. Eventually you have to put it together no matter who's blocking for you.

OH, the IRONY.

They rave about Bradford and how they "can't wait to see how well he does now that he has actual receivers to throw the football to". Yet, for McCoy "he is the top dog until Tannehill".

Colt gets a bad rap but he has no talent around him.

I think he can produce if he has the right pieces around him.