so i don't think i am gonna see eye with crash123go. we disagree on beadles and i will disagree on decker. your telling me 84 catches over 1000 yards and 13 td isn't good enough to be a high number 2 contract. most teams wish there number 2 would get over 1000 yards and over 10 td in a season
new york giants GM
more details to be posted
In 2011 Decker had 4 drops on 96 targets for a 4.17% drop rate. Demaryius had 6 on 69 targets for 8.7% drop rate.
Decker had 1 drop on 8 targets in 2010, that's not even close to a decent sample size. Demaryius had 2 on 39 targets, 5.13% drop rate.
He's had 4 drops this year in 2 career bad games. So what. It's not the end of the world like you pretend it is. The rest of his career when both of them saw more than 40 targets Decker has been a more reliable catcher than Demaryius.
You myths about how Decker has butterfingers and isn't a good #2 receiver are complete crap. You act like we can just go out and replace Decker with someone that has Demaryius' talent. This is the best receiving corps in the league and 2 bad games isn't reason to dump a guy who would be #2 on nearly any team in the league and #1 on half of them.
You have something personal against the guy, admit it. There's no basis for what you're saying.
Adopt-A-Poster: Peanut , MarkB
I like Decker a lot, but I don't think I would be willing to give him a big contract. I feel like he can be replaced if need be.
Backing Moreno, Ayers, and Smith for 09.
Supporting this staff!
Yes, I know my name is outdated, too lazy to care though hah = )
I'd love to keep Decker but if we need money aside for Thomas then I don't mind seeing him walk. It's the nature of the beast. If he wants too much money then we need to cut ties.
Sadly, as much as a Decker fan as I am, that guy is a train wreck. Even his good day last week was littered with bonehead moves. I would hate to see him go but would hate to keep him at the cost of that other talent that we need to re-sign.
Hes a disappointment hes supposed to be a reliable receiver, like rod smith. We need someone like Nate Burleson is now who can be a safety blanket.
Eddie Royals starting to look like a more reliable receiver
I am surprised we havent seen Jordan Matthews posts as a cousin of Jerry Rice, the blood enthusiasts would be all over this guy. Hes not athletic but hes a reliable receiver probably the 2nd most reliable receiver after Tulanes Ryan Grant. Yet he faces better talent
Last edited by Joshecalpoly; 09-23-2013 at 10:26 AM.