Originally posted by Max Power
View Post
Rodgers, knowing he's a "motivation/effort" problem is a 3rd or 4th round compensation right now. He's not exactly young anymore (not old, just not young) and does have a history of injury. Right now, he's not worth much more than Gerard Warren was when we traded for him from Cleveland. I'm thinking late third, high 4th round value, tops because he's a "risk"
Williams is young, and has flashed greatness, but he has also been injured and has disappeared in big games from time to time. Nobody really knows if it's him or just a poor Detroit offense. I think that he, much like Javon, merits a second round pick but not a first rounder.
If you add up a second for Williams and a third/fourth for Rogers, it doesn't add up to the #12 overall pick. I do, however, like the idea of swapping picks with Detroit (12 for 15) and maybe even a late rounder (5th or 7th) for Rogers. I wouldn't give up #12 overall for them, though.
Comment