Originally posted by ayacouby
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
TN Titan Michael Griffin
Collapse
X
-
-
-
Safety is not an easy position to transition too. It takes a lot of guys a couple years to figure it out, look at Michael Huff in Oakland, he struggled really for the first three years of his career and then he has started to play really well. That was a guy who wasn't only a 1st round pick, but actually had proper offseasons to go through. It is especially hard when you match two young safeties together as neither has someone to rely on, and young safeties aren't going to make communication amongst the secondary easy.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Al Wilson 4 Mayor View PostWe need a SS, not another FS.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Touch_30_Down View PostSafety is not an easy position to transition too. It takes a lot of guys a couple years to figure it out, look at Michael Huff in Oakland, he struggled really for the first three years of his career and then he has started to play really well. That was a guy who wasn't only a 1st round pick, but actually had proper offseasons to go through. It is especially hard when you match two young safeties together as neither has someone to rely on, and young safeties aren't going to make communication amongst the secondary easy.
Comment
-
Originally posted by beastlyskronk View PostAnd Michael Huff is probably one of the most physically gifted safeties in the NFL. S is a position that is based mainly on instincts and football intelligence. The most important physical ability to a S is his burst and it means nothing if his instincts and/or football intelligence are bad. Long speed doesn't mean anything if he can't accelerate to jump a route or accelerate to get over the top. A S doesn't need 4.3 or even 4.4 speed to be good. 4.5 and 4.6 are fine if he has great acceleration. Rahim Moore ran a 4.52 at his Pro Day and he has a 1.56 10 yard split. Eric Berry ran a 4.47 and has a 1.54 10 yard split. That acceleration is what allows Berry to be great, not being .05 seconds faster. Carter had a 1.62 10 yard split fwiw. Moore also has better hips than Carter.
Instincts, football intelligence, and experience are way more important than athletic ability at the safety position. The more football you play, and the more offseasons you have the better you are going to get at the mental aspects of the game which is probably the most important part for a safety. While I wouldn't be opposed to bringing in a veteran safety if Dawkins does indeed retire to mentor these guys and ease their transition into the NFL, I don't think spending a good deal of money for a fairly young safety is a good use of money for this team when we have two potential starters waiting. All I want to point out is that when you put two young safeties together without a proper offseason for either of them, you aren't looking at a recipe for success. You are putting them in a position to fail, and that's what they've done. With some time, and an actual offseason both Carter and Moore can become really good players. We've already seen how quick judgments on secondary players can allow other teams to pick up our trash and use their natural talents to be pretty good players (Alphonso Smith).
Comment
-
Originally posted by Touch_30_Down View PostYou're right.
Instincts, football intelligence, and experience are way more important than athletic ability at the safety position. The more football you play, and the more offseasons you have the better you are going to get at the mental aspects of the game which is probably the most important part for a safety. While I wouldn't be opposed to bringing in a veteran safety if Dawkins does indeed retire to mentor these guys and ease their transition into the NFL, I don't think spending a good deal of money for a fairly young safety is a good use of money for this team when we have two potential starters waiting. All I want to point out is that when you put two young safeties together without a proper offseason for either of them, you aren't looking at a recipe for success. You are putting them in a position to fail, and that's what they've done. With some time, and an actual offseason both Carter and Moore can become really good players. We've already seen how quick judgments on secondary players can allow other teams to pick up our trash and use their natural talents to be pretty good players (Alphonso Smith).
Comment
-
Originally posted by beastlyskronk View PostExactly, Moore has already shown some flashes this year. While they've been few and far between, I think he's really going to develop quite nicely next year. Carter might take a little longer and I think he's ultimately going to be the more prototypical "box SS". Hopefully he can turn into Sam Brandon coverage wise though. I like both of them, I think Carter definitely has the tools but this year, he looks nothing like he did in college. I can actually say the same for Moore, but it's more a positive for him because he's been a lot more aggressive when hitting WRs in the NFL. I never saw those big hits in college.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Touch_30_Down View PostYou're right.
Instincts, football intelligence, and experience are way more important than athletic ability at the safety position. The more football you play, and the more offseasons you have the better you are going to get at the mental aspects of the game which is probably the most important part for a safety. While I wouldn't be opposed to bringing in a veteran safety if Dawkins does indeed retire to mentor these guys and ease their transition into the NFL, I don't think spending a good deal of money for a fairly young safety is a good use of money for this team when we have two potential starters waiting. All I want to point out is that when you put two young safeties together without a proper offseason for either of them, you aren't looking at a recipe for success. You are putting them in a position to fail, and that's what they've done. With some time, and an actual offseason both Carter and Moore can become really good players. We've already seen how quick judgments on secondary players can allow other teams to pick up our trash and use their natural talents to be pretty good players (Alphonso Smith).
Which veteran do you think would be good to bring in if indeed Dawkins retires
Comment
-
Honestly there isn't anyone that can replace Dawkins, but there are a group of safeties in their early 30's/late 20's that are solid players that could teach these guys the game while being a stopgap at the position.
Jordan Babineux, Reggie Nelson, and Chris Hope are possibilities. But for me I'd say the most reasonable option would be Chris Harris. He has connections to John Fox, and he's a solid safety even if he did play bad earlier this year. He'd be affordable and yet still play at a fairly high level.
The best safeties that are free agents this year are all fairly young 25-27 range, which includes Goldson, DeCoud, Landry, Griffin, and Branch. Most of those guys are probably going to be retained, and if they aren't I would think they'd be offered pretty good sized contracts. And frankly since I think Carter and Moore will be good with time, I don't think investing that money into one of these guys would be all that wise.Last edited by Touch_30_Down; 12-29-2011, 01:05 AM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by Touch_30_Down View PostMoore's instincts have generally been on point, he seems to be in good positions to make plays which is a plus. The problem is he isn't really executing at all, he's dropped a couple balls and he's missed tackles. Those things are a lot easier to fix though. As for Carter, he's played like garbage the last few games but earlier in the year he was playing fine in coverage and was tackling well with Dawkins by his side. So I'm pretty optimistic there as well.
Comment
-
Originally posted by SoundsOfSuccess View PostDenver already has two young safeties.
Save the money for a larger need and get more of a vet.
I think Carter has played pretty bad as well. but he gets over shadowed by Moores dreadful season. Its nice to have a team that can have competition at a position and that would definitely create that.
Your second sentence doesn't make a whole lot of sense. Get a more of a vet? Griffin is a vet. please clarifyThe fool who fancies he is full of wisdom
While he sits by his hearth at home.
Quickly finds when questioned by others .
That he knows nothing at all.
Comment
Comment