Tom Brady vs Peyton Manning

[RandomVariable]

Premise: Peyton Manning just never had the defense to support him like Tom Brady did.

Analysis: Official NFL Team Defensive Rankings (yards allowed)
Patriots 2001: 24
Colts 2001: 29

Patriots 2002: 26
Colts 2002: 8

Patriots 2003: 7
Colts 2003: 11

Patriots 2004: 9
Colts 2004: 29

Patriots 2005: 26
Colts 2005: 11

Patriots 2006: 6
Colts 2006: 21

Patriots 2007: 4
Colts 2007: 3

Patriots 2008: skipped (no Brady)
Colts 2008: 11

Patriots 2009: 11
Colts 2009: 18

Patriots 2010: 25
Colts 2010: 20

Patriots 2011: 31
Colts 2011: skipped (no Manning)

10 year average ranking
Patriots: 16.9
Colts: 16.1

Conclusion: The premise is flawed

Brady > Manning

[#87Birdman]

Premise: Peyton Manning just never had the defense to support him like Tom Brady did.

Analysis: Official NFL Team Defensive Rankings (yards allowed)
Patriots 2001: 24
Colts 2001: 29

Patriots 2002: 26
Colts 2002: 8

Patriots 2003: 7
Colts 2003: 11

Patriots 2004: 9
Colts 2004: 29

Patriots 2005: 26
Colts 2005: 11

Patriots 2006: 6
Colts 2006: 21

Patriots 2007: 4
Colts 2007: 3

Patriots 2008: skipped (no Brady)
Colts 2008: 11

Patriots 2009: 11
Colts 2009: 18

Patriots 2010: 25
Colts 2010: 20

Patriots 2011: 31
Colts 2011: skipped (no Manning)

10 year average ranking
Patriots: 16.9
Colts: 16.1

Conclusion: The premise is flawed

Brady > Manning

yards lead to points? Just using one factor doesn't prove anything.

[58Miller]

yards lead to points? Just using one factor doesn't prove anything.

Video taping defensive signals also leads to points!

[RandomVariable]

Video taping defensive signals also leads to points!

Why are you making stuff up?

[Beagle]

Why are you making stuff up?

lol I see what you did there...making things up about making things up...its a paradox:thumb:you win a Bawl of Chowdaaah!



Now lets look at what really matters..the pats defenders are falling like old fat flies and the pats wrs are a joke...all this adds up to an arse whooping in Foxburrough .have fun with that

[RandomVariable]

lol I see what you did there...making tings up about making things up...its a paradox:thumb:



Now lets look at what really matters..the pats defenders are falling like old fat flies and the pats wrs are a joke...all this adds up to an arse whooping in Foxburrough .have fun with that

That's been happening for weeks yet we're still top 5 in scoring D. LOL @ thinking Manning will win in the cold in Foxboro.

[58Miller]

Why are you making stuff up?

Why did the nfl take a first round pick from New England?
Why are they 0-2 in Superbowls since they were found out?

[Beagle]

Okay so I decided to do a Brady Manning comparison myself and here is what i get..Manning has a superior intellect for the game,better stats across the board and calls his own plays for the most part. Plays for the Broncos a team known to pay its players for their great play over the years.Manning has a beautiful wife and 2 kids I have never even heard the woman talk much less talk about football and wouldn't know her if I ran into her on the street which is good in 2 ways keeps her and the kids safe and she probably doesn't know crap about football any way.

Brady has an inferior intellect for the game there for isn't allowed to call his own plays,lesser stats across the board and road superior defensive teams tails and cheated to win 3 superbowls 2 more than manning has currently has.Plays for the patriots known for using players fon the cheap for as long as possible and then releasing them/let them leave so they dont have to pay anyone.He also has a child with a woman that he left in the middle of her pregnancy for a super model(****** move). Super model wife likes to talk crap about his teammates when after not being allowed to cheat any more can no longer win big game!

Advantage Manning sorry

[58Miller]

Why are you making stuff up?

Wikipedia made this up under Spy Gate:
lAfter an investigation, the NFL fined Patriots head coach Bill Belichick $500,000 (the maximum allowed by the league and the largest fine ever imposed on a coach in the league's 87-year history) for his role in the incident, fined the Patriots $250,000, and docked the team their original first-round selection in the 2008 NFL Draft.

[Beagle]

That's been happening for weeks yet we're still top 5 in scoring D. LOL @ thinking Manning will win in the cold in Foxboro.

has way more to do with who you played than how you played..the first semi good O you played threw up 27 and left 3 tds on the field..manning wont leave TDs on the Field.


You might want to leave last time you came here talking trash your team lost and you had to do the disappearing act.

[58Miller]

Okay so I decided to do a Brady Manning comparison myself and here is what i get..Manning has a superior intellect for the game,better stats across the board and calls his own plays for the most part. Plays for the Broncos a team known to pay its players for their great play over the years.Manning has a beautiful wife and 2 kids I have never even heard the woman talk much less talk about football and wouldn't know her if I ran into her on the street which is good in 2 ways keeps her and the kids safe and she probably doesn't know crap about football any way.

Brady has an inferior intellect for the game there for isn't allowed to call his own plays,lesser stats across the board and road superior defensive teams tails and cheated to win 3 superbowls 2 more than manning has currently has.Plays for the patriots known for using players fon the cheap for as long as possible and then releasing them/let them leave so they dont have to pay anyone.He also has a child with a woman that he left in the middle of her pregnancy for a super model(****** move). Super model wife likes to talk crap about his teammates when after not being allowed to cheat any more can no longer win big game!

Advantage Manning sorry

He really thought he won a bawl of Chawda! He logged off and now he's eating it and watching his bootleg copy of Good Will Hunting!!!
How you like dose apples? Wicked!

[RandomVariable]

has way more to do with who you played than how you played..the first semi good O you played threw up 27 and left 3 tds on the field..manning wont leave TDs on the Field.


You might want to leave last time you came here talking trash your team lost and you had to do the disappearing act.

The points allowed were deceptive. We held them to something like 340 yards and completely shut down down Jimmy Graham who had 4 or 5 consecutive 100 yard games prior to that.

[RandomVariable]

And the Saints D is much better than yours. Brady will easily carve it.

[ruksak]

Pie > Cake

[Beagle]

The points allowed were deceptive. We held them to something like 340 yards and completely shut down down Jimmy Graham who had 4 or 5 consecutive 100 yard games prior to that.

The only weapon they have...we have a few more than that..GL stoping them all.Choose well. Brady can carve all he wants your WRS suck and drop more balls than your mom at a frat party