Does Peyton go in as a Colt or a Bronco?

[onanygivensunda]

Of course, it's quite a number of years away... maybe 7 or 8 given the mandatory 5-year waiting period.. but what's your best guess...

Does Peyton go into the HoF as a Colt (14 years of wearing the horseshoe) or a Bronco (4, maybe 5 years of wearing orange)?

And what, if anything, does Peyton's decision hinge on? Perhaps another SB experience or two?

Or do you feel that he's already made up his mind given the way Irsay let him go.

He and Irsay were tight as ticks at one time... were they not?

What's your opinion?

[58 broncomaniac]

The only way I see him going as a Bronco is if he is really that upset about how Irsay handled it. He will be breaking all the passing records in a Broncos uniform though..........so maybe. Or if he wins the next three Superbowls.

When its all said and done though I think he goes in as a Colt.

[johntbronco]

I thought the HOF you go in as a person representing your career work. Who cares if its Indy or Denver. There is no question his is one of the greatest.

[onanygivensunda]

Who cares if its Indy or Denver.

I'm guessing that there will be MANY fans of both teams who will care.

[baphamet]

I thought the HOF you go in as a person representing your career work. Who cares if its Indy or Denver. There is no question his is one of the greatest.

yes, you don't go in the HOF as a member of any team. but if he did? of course he would be a colt. he spent a lot more years there and won a championship there.

if peyton played a few more years and won a couple rings in denver, then maybe it would be different.

[EddieMac]

Why is this smack? Seems like a legit question and conversation.

THe summer heat must be getting to everyone,haha

[Houshmazode]

This is a dumb question to me, he should go in as a Colt.

[dizzolve]

I'll respect whatever he chooses to do.

Maybe he'll change the way things are done even after he's retired. Could be possibly be the first to go under 2 titles?

Surely he'll need to win a world championship in Denver for the Broncos to be a possibility.

Then again, maybe he does have a chip on his shoulder about the Indy thing.

One thing we can all be sure of though is that Manning will take the high road. Whatever that may be.

It's an interesting question to ponder.

If he wins 2 SB's as a Bronco - I think Denver could be a possibility.

[58Miller]

I'll respect whatever he chooses to do.

Maybe he'll change the way things are done even after he's retired. Could be possibly be the first to go under 2 titles?

Surely he'll need to win a world championship in Denver for the Broncos to be a possibility.

Then again, maybe he does have a chip on his shoulder about the Indy thing.

One thing we can all be sure of though is that Manning will take the high road. Whatever that may be.

It's an interesting question to ponder.

If he wins 2 SB's as a Bronco - I think Denver could be a possibility.

Winning 2 is the only way he would even think about it.

[RolandDeschain]

He'd have to win two more rings to go in as a Bronco.

[gorky]

There is very little doubt he will go in as a Colt.

[Mr Bojangles]

Winning 2 is the only way he would even think about it.

So we're all in agreement.......He'll go in as a Colt.:thumb:

[allthings18]

As I'm sure others have mentioned, an NFL player simply goes into the hall of fame. They list his teams and years of service on the display.

With that said, I hope when he does retire(hopefully not any time soon). I hope he retires as a Denver Bronco and doesn't give the joke of an owner the satisfaction of a one day contract to retire as a Colt.



But as to "going in as" This isn't baseball.

[58Miller]

So we're all in agreement.......He'll go in as a Colt.:thumb:

Hahaha!.... I hope not!

[onanygivensunda]

Is that a jersey that Joe is wearing?

If so, whose?