No announcement yet.

Who was better

  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Who was better

    Settle an argument between my two friends. They both were QBs of the same high school team, and I actually now wanna know which one is better. I’m gonna give a brief overview of both of them. Give me your honest answer. Im pretty biased towards 2012 because I played with him. 12’ had slightly better receivers, 14’ slightly better running backs. So we need some help, which one was better? I’m only providing their senior season stats for various reasons. 12’ has a slightly flashier highlight tape.

    Strengths of QBs:
    2012: Arm strength, Athleticism
    2014: Accuracy, Football IQ


    2012: Duel Threat QB
    -2.5 year starter. He was on a bad team his sophomore year (3-7) and was OK at best, was jus flat out bad his junior year (3TDs,7INT, 600 yards-46% comp.) was benched for a couple games mid season. Team finished 6-4 missed playoffs.
    -team ran a run oriented pistol scheme. Ran a decent amount of information though.
    -his RBs had 212 carries

    2012 Season stats: Captain (5-5)

    79/151-(52%)-1167yds-8TDs/14INTs-(116 QBR/59 Passer Rating) (0/2 two point conv.) (7.7 YPA)

    Rushing: 114/290/2TDs/2 Fumb/ 2.5 YPC
    (1 rush TD was 1 yard QB sneak.)

    2014: (pocket passer)
    -1 year starter (JV/Backup QB soph/junior year)
    -played in pro style I formation offense (70/30 Run)
    -his RBs had 345 carries

    2014 season stats: Captain
    88/141-(62%)-1059yds-6TDs/5INTs-(132 QBR/84 passer Rating) (1/1 2 pt Conversions, it was a 2 pt throw to tie the game with 1:00 left.)(7.5 YPA)

  • #2
    Gotta go with 2014 QB. Higher completion percentage for close to same amount of yards and TD's, and fewer turnovers. Just my opinion. QB rush yards and TD's are nice, but running QB is usually more at risk for injury and the best ability for a QB is availability.