Who will win the heisman?

[BaileyTheBest]

The finalists have been announced.

[Nick]

Who will win is Smith, Who should win is no one

Except I think they should take in factor of a certain QB in the WAC do to what he has done not the talent involved in WAC.

Because if you have a bunch of decent teams playing eachother it should be reflected the same as some good teams playing against each other.

So I officially say that QB should be for Heisman and he would do better then quinn or smith at there school. Shoot I bet Brohm would do better.

[GridironChamp]

Smith will win, Brennan should win.

[tommy1986]

boringest heisman race ever.

[DrunkPanda]

i agree. none of these guys deserve to win it

[Straz1999]

Smith will win, Brennan should win.

What??? You are crazy man.

[broncofan303]

The guy that SHOULD win it is Troy Smith, but even though Im an Irish fan, I've got this sick feeling that Brady Quinn is going to win it...

[dogfish]

Troy Smith, but I don't think he should. Really, I don't think anyone should. Can we just not give the Heisman this year?

they should award it to vince retroactively. . . .

[RunYouOver]

Troy smith will win it, no doubt about that...

But Darren Mcfadden SHOULD win it....he's been absolutely unbelievable.


And no, GC, Colt Brennan shouldn't even be in the top 20...and he won't be.

[GridironChamp]

Troy smith will win it, no doubt about that...

But Darren Mcfadden SHOULD win it....he's been absolutely unbelievable.


And no, GC, Colt Brennan shouldn't even be in the top 20...and he won't be.

Yet, i think you dont even know who he is saying stuff like that.

Colt Brennan, the guy that's on pace to break the all time D I touchdown passes
record.
The guy averaging what was it over 10 yards per throw?
And the guy, that has SAT OUT MORE 4th QUARTERS THAN HE HAS PLAYED?

Saying he doesnt deserve it is stupid enough, but saying not top 20?

[stnzed]

Bernard Jackson!


But Darren McFadden should!

[RunYouOver]

Yet, i think you dont even know who he is saying stuff like that.

Colt Brennan, the guy that's on pace to break the all time D I touchdown passes
record.
The guy averaging what was it over 10 yards per throw?
And the guy, that has SAT OUT MORE 4th QUARTERS THAN HE HAS PLAYED?

Saying he doesnt deserve it is stupid enough, but saying not top 20?

He isn't top 20.

Wait until you see the voting.

I'm telling you, Hawaii is a passing offense, that's how their entire offense is set up...if they want their QBs to get more glory and consideration, they'll have to schedule real opponents.

[Calif. Bronco]

He isn't top 20.

Wait until you see the voting.

I'm telling you, Hawaii is a passing offense, that's how their entire offense is set up...if they want their QBs to get more glory and consideration, they'll have to schedule real opponents.

Don't get Hawaii mixed up with some of those other WAC teams Run - they do at least try and schedule decent non-conference opponents. This year, for example, they played Alabama, Purdue, and Oregon State. Last year they played USC and Michigan State, for example.

For the record, I think Troy Smith deserves to win and is going to win, but I had to clear up the misconception that Hawaii plays a bunch of nobodies.

[D.J.55]

troy smith hands down. after he beat michigan, he became the lock for the heisman.

[Nick7]

Smith will win, Brennan should win.

Hawaii's strength of schedule rank is 93rd.

Do feel like retracting that last statement, buddy?