Originally posted by KansasKrista
View Post
For example:
Kyle Orton: Look at his time with Chicago. Top defense. Run game. All he had to do was manage the game and not make mistakes. They won with him but they didn't win cause of him. He was 21-12.
Tim Tebow: If this defense didn't show up we were essentially done. The one exeption was the Vikings game where the defense still scored a TD and got the pick to seal it. The games we won this defense allowed an amazing 16.9 points per game. That is amazing. That is elite defense right there. He was a part of the team but was not the reason we were there.
Joe Flacco: His record since he entered the league. He is 44-20 as a starter. He is a very average QB. His team was in it not because of him. He was just there.
Matt Cassel: In 2008 and 2010 he had winning records and a combined record of 20-10. Both of those years he was just average and due to a very good team around him he was there. He had the previously 18-1 Patriots team and a Kansas City team with the top rushing attack in the NFL and a solid defense. They made the playoffs in 2010 in spite of him.
Mark Sanchez: His team had him in the confrence round of the playoffs two years in a row. He is bad. He was there cause of his team. Over 3 seasons he has a 27-20 record. He is one of the worst in the league.
Alex Smith: After years of failure and despite actually good and much improved individual performance his team is so good. A huge reason he had a shot to compete for a trip to the superbowl yesterday.
All of these examples of some of the worst and most average quarterbacks in the league shows that a quarterback should not just be measured by wins and losses as the quarterbacks like on this list show can still win with great teams.
It is something that makes me laugh with those that defend Tebow with the expert analysis of he is a winner. I especially love the use of it by the media guys like Brandon Spanno, DMAC and Skip Bayless. They like a lot of others don't have the understanding to actually break down Tebow's play so they say to legit critique and concerns about his play with oh I don't care he is a winner.
And I highly doubt Cassel would beat out Orton. Cassel is one of the worst quarterbacks in the league along with the guys above I just mentioned however Orton is better. I think if the Cheifs can rid of the salary they have tied to Cassel and get rid of him they will. I think Orton starts for Kansas City in 2012. He was instrumental in getting Romeo the job in Kansas City. I am sure after going 2-1 with him Romeo will try to keep Orton around.
Comment