Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

At least we can put away the greatest ever debate

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #16
    Originally posted by Apoc13 View Post
    and people say parcells hasn;t won since belichick left...and they can say belichick hasn;t won since romeo crennel left
    Or you can say they haven't won since Josh McD's been there. LOL

    Comment


    • #17
      He'll still be in the debate in my opinion
      sigpic
      Thank you Charger$

      Comment


      • #18
        Originally posted by Apoc13 View Post
        agreed.. but even if they were to win a couple more superbowls somebody will always say, yeah but coughlin/eli were better than they were...and how can you argue?
        If Brady/Belichick were to win another Super Bowl they would be hands down the best just by going to 6 Super Bowls and winning 4. Getting to six Super Bowls as a head coach or as a starting QB is an amazing feat no matter how you look at it and winning 4 of them would tie the best that any coach or starting QB has ever done. Unless Coughlin and Eli win at least one more Super Bowl, they'll never be mentioned as one of the greatest coach/qb pairing. Just winning 2 in 8 seasons together doesn't get you there.
        2 of the top 3 NFL QBs of all time have been Broncos

        Comment


        • #19
          Originally posted by BroncsSB#3 View Post
          If Brady/Belichick were to win another Super Bowl they would be hands down the best just by going to 6 Super Bowls and winning 4. Getting to six Super Bowls as a head coach or as a starting QB is an amazing feat no matter how you look at it and winning 4 of them would tie the best that any coach or starting QB has ever done. Unless Coughlin and Eli win at least one more Super Bowl, they'll never be mentioned as one of the greatest coach/qb pairing. Just winning 2 in 8 seasons together doesn't get you there.
          and. as i said, somebody will say coughlin and eli were better......and they were and you won't have an argument besides, but, but, but...

          there is no argument for noll/bradshaw or walsh/montana like that

          Comment


          • #20
            Originally posted by Apoc13 View Post
            and. as i said, somebody will say coughlin and eli were better......and they were and you won't have an argument besides, but, but, but...

            there is no argument for noll/bradshaw or walsh/montana like that
            Coughlin and Eli aren't even in the running, regardless of them winning the 2 Super Bowls, so they wouldn't be brought up as better except by people that hate the Pats. If Coughlin and Eli had a 20-5 record against Belichick and Brady and just owned them year after year, it would be different or if Coughlin and Eli won 3 or 4 Super Bowls together it would be different. For now, they aren't in the discussion for best coach/QB combo, so that argument that they are better than Belichick and Brady is pointless.
            2 of the top 3 NFL QBs of all time have been Broncos

            Comment


            • #21
              Originally posted by BroncsSB#3 View Post
              Coughlin and Eli aren't even in the running, regardless of them winning the 2 Super Bowls, so they wouldn't be brought up as better except by people that hate the Pats. If Coughlin and Eli had a 20-5 record against Belichick and Brady and just owned them year after year, it would be different or if Coughlin and Eli won 3 or 4 Super Bowls together it would be different. For now, they aren't in the discussion for best coach/QB combo, so that argument that they are better than Belichick and Brady is pointless.
              so brady/belichick and their 3 superbowl wins are better than eli/coughlin and their two wins...even though eli/coughlin beat them head to head twice

              Comment


              • #22
                Originally posted by Apoc13 View Post
                so brady/belichick and their 3 superbowl wins are better than eli/coughlin and their two wins...even though eli/coughlin beat them head to head twice
                Brady/Belichick and their 3 Super Bowl wins AND their 5 Super Bowl appearances, and their most wins of any coach/QB in NFL history, and all the team passing and individual passing records the Pats broke during the Brady/Belichick era, and the fact that both of them are already first-ballot HOFers as is make them much better than Eli/Coughlin's two Super Bowl wins. There is no head to head for Brady and Eli. They don't play defense against each other, so head to head comparisons don't matter with them or any other 2 QBs that play each other's team.

                Brady/Belichick have a huge resume that puts them in the argument.

                Eli/Coughlin have 2 Super Bowl wins and that's it so far.
                2 of the top 3 NFL QBs of all time have been Broncos

                Comment


                • #23
                  I agree with BroncosSB#3, if Brady/Belechik make it again, and win one, very possible.

                  Winnable division, AFC is declining, lot of draft picks, probably get Lloyd since he's tied with McDaniels among other things.

                  Make 6 SB's, win 4, 2 of the losses were close.

                  Yes, i'd say it's the best coach/QB duo all-time as well.

                  Comment


                  • #24
                    Seems like Belichick got out coached anyway:

                    Tom Brady and the Patriots ran 72 plays with a no-huddle offense in the first two games of the playoffs, accounting for over half of their plays from scrimmage. However, in Super Bowl XLVI the Patriots ran the no huddle for only 10 plays, using it on only three drives- two of which ended in touchdowns.
                    and

                    NEXT LEVEL: The Patriots began the game with their base 3-4 defense on the field for 8 of the Giants' first 11 plays, and used it 56 percent of the time in the first half. They then switched to their base 4-3 predominantly in the second half, and allowed twice as many yards per play in the process.
                    Seems like some odd moves considering....
                    sigpic


                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X