Who is your ROTY so far ?

[bronx_2003]

I guess it comes down to 3. RG3, Luck and D Martin.

For me it has to be Griffin. I know there's always been this hype about Luck, and he has done well, but I think Griffin has been on a higher level this season, with less team talent, IMO.

Both have played 11 games.

Griffin - 67.5 (Completion %), 16 TD's, 4 Int's - 642 rushing yards, 6 TD's

Luck - 56.8 (Completion %), 13 TD's, 13 Int's - 183 rushing yards, 5 TD's

The Colts are 7-4 and the Skins are 5-6. I have never been a fan of using a W-L record when comparing QB's. Too much depends on team talent and schedules, plus other variables.

[one5beast]

OROY - RG3
DROY - This one is hard. No one is having that Von Miller, Aldon Smith type impact. Maybe Kuechly or Casey Hayward

[TheSheriff]

RG3 and Kuechly

[MileHighMaven]

For me it's definitely RG3

[orangenightmare]

Andrew Luck.... 2-14 team to probably making the playoffs... incredible without even factoring in the loss of several good veterans from that team . Lot of football to be played and RG3 looks greats but I think Luck will earn the OROY and deservedly so. Doug Martin has been awesome as well. Im guessing kuechly will get DROY of there year but i dunno. Chandler Jones possibly. How has fletcher Cox been?

[assassin216]

You gotta throw in Doug Martin into the mix...

[canadiansbronco]

1-RG3
2-Luck
3-Martin

[bears6385]

Andrew Luck.... 2-14 team to probably making the playoffs... incredible without even factoring in the loss of several good veterans from that team . Lot of football to be played and RG3 looks greats but I think Luck will earn the OROY and deservedly so. Doug Martin has been awesome as well. Im guessing kuechly will get DROY of there year but i dunno. Chandler Jones possibly. How has fletcher Cox been?

I would also go with Luck..........47 new players on that team at the start of the season, and still a playoff run. That is amazing.

[baphamet]

probably luck due to the adversity and winning but its definitely close between him and RG3 IMO

[theMileHighGuy]

Luck also doesn't have Alfred Morris, who's name probably shouldn't be completely thrown out of the race. He's not very far behind Doug Martin and I don't think he's had as many carries. Martin Scoreseasy does also have 300 some receiving yards though to his credit. Either way Morris is a big part of why RG3 has done so well. Not saying RG3 isn't awesome or anything, he's amazing.

[beastlyskronk]

I think RG3 should get oroy but it'll probably go to Luck. Defensively I really don't think it's close, Lavonte David has been nothing short of amazing for Tampa Bay. He doesn't have the INTs/FFs you looks for in a LB but he's close to 100 tackles and he's not too far behind Von Miller in TFLs.

I take that back. Casey Hayward has been very good in Green Bay as well

[BroncoFanBoy]

I would say Luck since he has Indianapolis, who were 2-14 last year, in the playoff hunt. True, they may be playing a last place schedule, but this is still pretty impressive. Luck has a good future in the NFL.

RGIII is better stats-wise, but Luck is winning more games than RGIII.

[orangenightmare]

Regardless of who gets it, I will enjoy watching these guys play for years to come.

[Yakka27]

I think it's impossible to ignore what Andrew Luck is doing to that team. The Colts have a legitimate shot from going from the #1 pick to the playoffs.

[SBboundBRONCOS]

Russel Wilson