Originally posted by InElwayWeTrust
View Post
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
Andy Reid and Kansas City on verge of a deal
Collapse
X
-
Originally posted by CanDB View PostSo who's his QB going to be, because "to be fair", he hasn't got one now.
Does he go after an existing one or draft somene like Geno Smith? As far as I can tell, this team's future rests on that decision. I've written about it elsewhere. KC could be a good team with a quality QB. Of course that can be said for a lot of teams, but in my opinion, they can easily go from 2 and 14 to 8 and 8 with a few good moves. But a rookie QB will take longer.....unless there's another Luck or RGIII or Russ Wilson out there.
Honestly I think it has to be someone better than Alex Smith or a Matt Flynn though. Those are above average game managers but in no way elite QB's. I could see Smith regressing in K.C. I think you're right though that Reid and Smith could probably get them back to 8-8. And make it really tough for us to win in K.C. again.
Fox took us from 4-12 to 8-8 immediately with Tebow. So .500 is not out of the realm of possibility with an average qb.
However I don't think Reid has a qb that can be available in the next season or two to make them playoff contenders. It would take longer but they really need to draft and mold someone. That is their best chance at coming across an elite qb. I just don't see them coming across an elite one next year so for at least 1 year Reid is a non factor.
After that we'll look again at their options and reassess.sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by DenverBlood View PostThat's why as of today I'm not scared of this hiring. I don't think anyone can win in K.C. with their current QB situation. Same to be said if he went to Arizona. Reid is not a miracle worker.
Honestly I think it has to be someone better than Alex Smith or a Matt Flynn though. Those are above average game managers but in no way elite QB's. I could see Smith regressing in K.C. I think you're right though that Reid and Smith could probably get them back to 8-8. And make it really tough for us to win in K.C. again.
Fox took us from 4-12 to 8-8 immediately with Tebow. So .500 is not out of the realm of possibility with an average qb.
However I don't think Reid has a qb that can be available in the next season or two to make them playoff contenders. It would take longer but they really need to draft and mold someone. That is their best chance at coming across an elite qb. I just don't see them coming across an elite one next year so for at least 1 year Reid is a non factor.
After that we'll look again at their options and reassess.
Maybe they trade down and go after Barkley or Gino?
Comment
-
Not a surprise. Reid like draft picks, and KC got the #1 spot. I wouldn't be surprised if he tried to trade for Matt Flynn and then use the #1 pick to accumulate other picks. IMO, KC has been a QB away from being a real threat in the AFC West and the league, period. This signing would be good for the division!sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by Spice 1 View PostYep. Based on history, Reid isn't going to want a game manager.
Maybe they trade down and go after Barkley or Gino?
I think they should take Teo and a Qb in round 2. Not sure who but I can't imagine there isn't someone quality after those two names. I just don't know who it is. I mean Wilson was drafted 5th round.sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by DenverBlood View PostHonestly I'm not that impressed with either of those. I've actually seena projection they take Gino #1 overall. Which I think is a huge mistake.
I think they should take Teo and a Qb in round 2. Not sure who but I can't imagine there isn't someone quality after those two names. I just don't know who it is. I mean Wilson was drafted 5th round.
Comment
-
Originally posted by DenverBlood View PostHonestly I'm not that impressed with either of those. I've actually seena projection they take Gino #1 overall. Which I think is a huge mistake.
I think they should take Teo and a Qb in round 2. Not sure who but I can't imagine there isn't someone quality after those two names. I just don't know who it is. I mean Wilson was drafted 5th round.sigpic2012 Broncos Country Pick 'Em Challenge Champion
Comment
-
Originally posted by TH3JUICEMAN View PostIn his first year as a HC of the Eagles (1999) Reid drafted McNabb. Reid loves athletic mobile QB's. I would almost guarantee if he is their HC he will draft Geno Smith #1sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by TH3JUICEMAN View PostIn his first year as a HC of the Eagles (1999) Reid drafted McNabb. Reid loves athletic mobile QB's. I would almost guarantee if he is their HC he will draft Geno Smith #1
Comment
-
Originally posted by TH3JUICEMAN View PostIn his first year as a HC of the Eagles (1999) Reid drafted McNabb. Reid loves athletic mobile QB's. I would almost guarantee if he is their HC he will draft Geno Smith #1sigpic
Comment
-
Originally posted by Roddoliver View PostOr Tajh Boyd, who has more arm talent and upside than Geno Smith IMO.
I thought he was a freshman sensation last year along with Sammy Watkins?
Do we even know he would come out even if he is a junior?sigpic
Comment
Comment