Best QB, out of theese

[Rollo]

Who Is The Best QB, out of theese

[Nick]

I put Mcnair because mainly was able to show he was able to be a team leader and pull a team with "Mason" as his #1 wide receiver.

He was tough and was able to play through injuries.

Eli is to young in the league to put in group as of yet.. Even though he has been developing to be a very good QB.

Mcnabb... well I think he is very very overated.. and I actually think it would be more debatable with him saying whos better between him and plummer.

Cullpeper had a lot of compliments when was being successfull, and failed with no compliments unlike some people on this list (excluding Mcnabb)

Brees is a tough one. He has shown to be a good QB.. well very good QB but also had one of the best RB's and TE in league complimenting him. He is very accurate what I seen couple years ago when was in the accuracy competition (when throwing through tires) (note:Vick did the worst)

so brees is my runner up.

[KCLadyFan]

what....no Payton :

[WhoDeyBengals]

what....no Payton :

If I had to guess, the question's written this way because of a fantasy football problem.

I'd take Manning.

[Emancipator]

I'll go with McNabb for the ones you've listed.

[UnderArmour]

I think Culpepper is a tad better than McNabb.

[Snapping Turtle]

McNabb methinks....if anything he's exciting to watch.

[The Dark Knight]

I think Culpepper is a tad better than McNabb.

No way.

Culpepper has never won anything. Even when he had help.

McNabb has at least made it to the Superbowl.

[Charlie Brown]

McNabb. hands down. He is the only one still with the team he had success with. All the others are in new systems and there is no telling how they will do. Also with Eli he hasn't had much success.

[NJBRONCOSFAN]

I'm going with Eli...if he makes improvements like he did last year, he'll definitely be better than this group.

He had better stats them most all of the other qb's listed, and he was also able to stay healthy.

He's also surrounded by the most talent.

[Giveemlove]

Out of the guys listed...gotta be McNabb. But what is with this question...besides Manning, it could be seen as the Which QB has had the most injuries and who is most likely to come back strong.

[Medford Bronco]

I like Drew Brees. He i believe is on his way to superstardom. He is well prepared and has improved each year in his career. IMHO

[Rollo]

what....no Payton :

my buddy, an eagles fan wanted 2 compare these guys

[NJBRONCOSFAN]

I like Drew Brees. He i believe is on his way to superstardom. He is well prepared and has improved each year in his career. IMHO

I would also pick Brees if he was still in SD with Gates and Tomlinson, but that injury of his is a question mark, and the Saints are perennial losers.

[Comrade]

If this is a fantasy football question, I would go with Eli.

If its just for general fun, I would say the best QB is McNabb, it doesnt look like he will get much help on the Eagles offense this season though.