Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Most overrated player(s) in the NFL?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • #31
    Originally posted by Broncs453 View Post
    This man speaks da truf.

    As for my overrated players:

    QB:
    Mike Vick
    Eli Manning
    Philip Rivers (take away LT and see how well he does...)

    RB:
    Reggie Bush (I expect this to change)
    Clinton Portis
    Brandon Jacobs

    WR:
    Wes Welker
    Mike Furrey


    Defense:
    Roy Williams
    Deangelo Hall
    Osi Umenyiora
    Joey Porter
    I agree with most except a couple.

    I don't understand how Jacobs is overrated when he hasn't had any playing time. He is being known as the next big rb in NY. But I don't believe he is overrated yet.

    Wes Welker aern't overrated they are just overpaid. Enough said.

    Roy Williams and Joey Porter are one of the tops at thier position in my opinion. Williams a tackling machine and with some ball skills. And Porter has the ability to get to the qb at any moment. Plus I can't hate a CSU grad (Porter).

    But the most overrated in the nfl in my opinion is everyone on the chargers. (Except LT)
    sigpic

    Comment


    • #32
      Originally posted by Atwnbroncfan View Post
      And Porter has the ability to get to the qb at any moment. Plus I can't hate a CSU grad (Porter).

      But the most overrated in the nfl in my opinion is everyone on the chargers. (Except LT)
      Porter is ridiculously overrated. He is very one-dimensional in that really all he does well is rush the passer. He isn't a great tackler, and contrary to popular belief he doesn't hit extremely hard. He is a liability in coverage, and he doesn't have the speed he once had that made up for him being a liability nor to nullify the fact that he doesn't play the run extremely well.

      Antonio Gates is nowhere near overrated. Shawne Merriman, if at all, is barely overrated and that is coming from someone who doesn't like Merriman at all. Also, Lorenzo Neal is easily one of the best, if not the best, FB in the league.




      Sig by Sky.:salute:

      All you nooby dooby doos need to stop making stupid threads.:coffee:

      Comment


      • #33
        Originally posted by Atwnbroncfan View Post
        I agree with most except a couple.

        I don't understand how Jacobs is overrated when he hasn't had any playing time. He is being known as the next big rb in NY. But I don't believe he is overrated yet.

        Wes Welker aern't overrated they are just overpaid. Enough said.

        Roy Williams and Joey Porter are one of the tops at thier position in my opinion. Williams a tackling machine and with some ball skills. And Porter has the ability to get to the qb at any moment. Plus I can't hate a CSU grad (Porter).

        But the most overrated in the nfl in my opinion is everyone on the chargers. (Except LT)
        there's a ****in surprise lol
        sigpic

        Comment


        • #34
          Originally posted by bengaaaaals1688 View Post
          Porter is ridiculously overrated. He is very one-dimensional in that really all he does well is rush the passer. He isn't a great tackler, and contrary to popular belief he doesn't hit extremely hard. He is a liability in coverage, and he doesn't have the speed he once had that made up for him being a liability nor to nullify the fact that he doesn't play the run extremely well.

          Antonio Gates is nowhere near overrated. Shawne Merriman, if at all, is barely overrated and that is coming from someone who doesn't like Merriman at all. Also, Lorenzo Neal is easily one of the best, if not the best, FB in the league.
          don't bother , it's just a broncos fan stocked up on haterade
          sigpic

          Comment


          • #35
            Originally posted by jcdavey View Post
            don't bother , it's just a broncos fan stocked up on haterade
            Probably, but it's fun to get people like that all riled up and watch them go off on rants trying to come up with logical reasons for people to be overrated.




            Sig by Sky.:salute:

            All you nooby dooby doos need to stop making stupid threads.:coffee:

            Comment


            • #36
              Originally posted by bengaaaaals1688 View Post
              Probably, but it's fun to get people like that all riled up and watch them go off on rants trying to come up with logical reasons for people to be overrated.
              oh i know haha, i've seen retarded opinions on my own team's board stating guys like lynch and bailey are overrated too, so i know about dealing with the mentally defficient
              sigpic

              Comment


              • #37
                Originally posted by jcdavey View Post
                oh i know haha, i've seen retarded opinions on my own team's board stating guys like lynch and bailey are overrated too, so i know about dealing with the mentally defficient
                Bengals board has been the worst I have seen with ridiculous claims of people being overrated or underrated. I go into our forum, that is like the orange colored glasses forum on here, specifically to laugh at the ridiculous things people come up with.




                Sig by Sky.:salute:

                All you nooby dooby doos need to stop making stupid threads.:coffee:

                Comment


                • #38
                  Originally posted by bengaaaaals1688 View Post
                  Bengals board has been the worst I have seen with ridiculous claims of people being overrated or underrated. I go into our forum, that is like the orange colored glasses forum on here, specifically to laugh at the ridiculous things people come up with.
                  hilarious, some of my teams fans want to cut darren sproles , can you believe that? haha
                  sigpic

                  Comment


                  • #39
                    Originally posted by jcdavey View Post
                    hilarious, some of my teams fans want to cut darren sproles , can you believe that? haha
                    When your fans say that you should get rid of your starting RB and one of the most consistent RB's the past like 4 years... you believe anything.


                    P.S. That wasn't a joke... there were a ridiculous amount of threads last year saying that we should get rid of Rudi.




                    Sig by Sky.:salute:

                    All you nooby dooby doos need to stop making stupid threads.:coffee:

                    Comment


                    • #40
                      Originally posted by bengaaaaals1688 View Post
                      When your fans say that you should get rid of your starting RB and one of the most consistent RB's the past like 4 years... you believe anything.


                      P.S. That wasn't a joke... there were a ridiculous amount of threads last year saying that we should get rid of Rudi.
                      my goodness...for what??? kenny irons?!
                      sigpic

                      Comment


                      • #41
                        Originally posted by Atwnbroncfan View Post
                        I agree with most except a couple.

                        I don't understand how Jacobs is overrated when he hasn't had any playing time. He is being known as the next big rb in NY. But I don't believe he is overrated yet.

                        Wes Welker aern't overrated they are just overpaid. Enough said.

                        Roy Williams and Joey Porter are one of the tops at thier position in my opinion. Williams a tackling machine and with some ball skills. And Porter has the ability to get to the qb at any moment. Plus I can't hate a CSU grad (Porter).

                        But the most overrated in the nfl in my opinion is everyone on the chargers. (Except LT)
                        Jacobs got a decent amount of playing time last year...he played in all but one game...96 carries isn't a lot by any means, but to say he hasn't had any playing time is a little off-base. I just think he's overrated because people seem to think he's awesome due to TDs he gets.

                        Let me put it this way about Welker/Furrey: Furrey won't have a year like he had last year, and I know a crapload of people who jumped on the Welker bandwagon and were saying he's awesome - 687 yds and 1 TD is hardly that.

                        Roy Williams can certainly hit hard, but I don't think he's a "tackling machine"

                        As for Porter, I'll reiterate what someone else said:
                        Originally posted by bengaaaaals1688
                        Porter is ridiculously overrated. He is very one-dimensional in that really all he does well is rush the passer. He isn't a great tackler, and contrary to popular belief he doesn't hit extremely hard. He is a liability in coverage, and he doesn't have the speed he once had that made up for him being a liability nor to nullify the fact that he doesn't play the run extremely well.
                        You saying he's "at the top of his position" proves that he is overrated. Check his stats.

                        Word.
                        :orton:

                        Comment


                        • #42
                          Originally posted by jcdavey View Post
                          my goodness...for what??? kenny irons?!
                          No... this was before we got Kenny Irons, this was when our back-up was Kenny Watson.




                          Sig by Sky.:salute:

                          All you nooby dooby doos need to stop making stupid threads.:coffee:

                          Comment


                          • #43
                            Randy moss...

                            Comment


                            • #44
                              Originally posted by Titans309Fan View Post


                              Please. Vince Young is a true quarterback who can run, as opposed to Vick, a running back who can pass.

                              Vince will be a superstar QB in the NFL. Last year, he was just getting his feet wet in the NFL. This will be his breakout year. Look how much Peyton Manning changed from his rookie year to his second year (as well as many star QBs). I expect Vince to do the same.

                              Also, did you see that game against the Giants last year. The team was down 21 points in the 4th quarter, and Vince almost singlehandedly won the game (with a couple of key interceptions by Pacman). So don't tell me what Vince can't do.

                              DING DING DING! There ya go! Vince young didn't win ANYTHING singlehandedly. In most of his wins, people like Henry and Pacman deserve as much if not more credit. Just watch how lousy the Titans are this season. It will prove that he is not able to singlehandedly win games.


                              Comment


                              • #45
                                Eli Manning
                                Ben Rothlisberger-I can't stand this guy

                                Michael Turner

                                Dante Stallworth
                                Dieon Branch

                                Daniel Graham

                                RICHARD SEYMORE!!!

                                Joey Porter-He doesn't dominate like he used to at all and got over paid for too long...
                                Teddy Bruschi*

                                Nate Clemens
                                Deangelo Hall
                                Shawn Taylor
                                "It's better to die on your feet, than to live a lifetime on your knees." -Emiliano Zapata
                                R.I.P. D-Will & D-Nash R.I.P. Sean Taylor

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X